Welcome to Old Chicago Pizza Taproom
Old Chicago Pizza Taproom, located at 383 Mopar Dr in Hays, KS, offers an enticing blend of gourmet pizzas and flavorful party platters. Known for its hearty calzones and savory spaghetti pies, the restaurant captures a unique spirit with a diverse range of signature sauces and dry rubs for wings. Diners rave about the tantalizing combinations and friendly service, creating a welcoming atmosphere perfect for families and travelers alike. Whether you're grabbing a slice or sharing a party pack, Old Chicago delivers a delightful dining experience sure to satisfy your cravings for authentic Italian flavors.
- 383 Mopar Dr, Hays, KS 67601, United States383 Mopar Dr, Hays, KS 67601, United States Hotline: +1 785-261-9728
Welcome to Old Chicago Pizza Taproom, a vibrant eatery nestled at 383 Mopar Dr, Hays, KS. This establishment has carved a niche for itself in the world of pizza lovers, celebrating the rich flavors of Chicago-style cuisine while offering a diversified menu that promises something for everyone. Whether you're in the mood for classic deep-dish pizza, crispy wings, or tantalizing handhelds, Old Chicago Pizza Taproom has you covered.
As you step inside, the ambiance buzzes with energy, ideal for family gatherings or a casual night out. With menu offerings like the Keg of Wings—a generous portion of traditional bone-in wings tossed in mouthwatering sauces—you'll understand why diners rave about their experience here. The Crafted Beer Burger is another standout, featuring a juicy patty grilled with a light lager for a unique and savory bite that pairs perfectly with crispy onion strings.
For fans of Italian fare, the calzones come highly recommended, with customers like Randy Miller highlighting their top-tier quality. The Chicago calzone has been described as a "fire" dish, indicating that it not only meets but surpasses expectations. It’s not surprising, given the culinary artistry that Old Chicago Pizza Taproom is known for.
Moreover, the staff genuinely enhances your dining experience, with numerous patrons mentioning their attentiveness and friendly demeanor. Customer reviews consistently applaud the service, highlighting individual staff members like Reed and Paul, who made dining here memorable even during long travels.
It’s important to note, however, that with any bustling venue, small hiccups in service may occur. Yet, the overall feedback reflects a strong commitment to customer satisfaction. Whether it’s a chilly atmosphere or an occasional delay, the emphasis is on delicious food, which is the main draw of Old Chicago Pizza Taproom.
Your visit to Old Chicago Pizza Taproom is sure to be rewarding. The heady combination of delicious food, inviting environment, and outstanding service creates a unique pizza experience that is worth every moment. So, if you're driving through Hays, don’t miss your chance to indulge in what many call "gourmet pizza" and more at this local gem.

Wow!! Freaking amazing!! One of the top calzones I’ve had in a long time. I eat lots of calzones and I’m going to be razing about this one for a while. I got the Chicago for calzone and it was fire. I would recommend this to anyone. The service was ok nothing special he wasn’t bad or great just the average you see now a day. I sat at the bar so you thought you would get a little more action or talking. Just did the basic.

One of the better pizza places. I would categorize this as Gourmet pizza. This one of the Great 4 pizza places in my collection 1. Old Chicago (Midwest) 2. BJ Chicago Pizza (Chicago Pizza California style) 3. Numero Uno Pizza (Southern California) 4. Fresh Brothers (Hollywood California) A superb tasty pizza will run you between 30-40 for a medium/large with about 7-8 toppings I always wanted to try this place first seeing it in Kansas City then off the freeway here in Fort Hays. The staff was super friendly and helpful. I'm a truck driver so I parked in the Walmart and walked over as no trucks are allowed and plus there isn't any room to tern around anyways. I will totally be back to grab another Pie. as I pass through 3 times a month

Reed was great! He was patient with the kids ordering. He got my 4 year old to eat his entire kids meal all because he told him he had brownies! Reed didn’t know but we are on hour 18 of what will be a 24 hour trip with our 5 kids ages 4 to 16. Thanks Reed for an amazing dinner and experience!

Night out with my girlfriend and her granddaughter. The service was great. The food was super good and exactly as ordered. The restaurant was clean but it was a bit chilly in there and usually is every time we go. Our server was wearing a lot of perfume, which was a bit off-putting.

Our server Paul (from Boston originally) was AWESOME!!! We were here just over a week ago and service was decidedly lacking then. Stayed in the same hotel on our travels back and decided to give this Old Chicago another try. Getting drinks still took some time but, again, Paul was great!!! Grilled chicken caprese sandwich was TASTY, too. Way too many TVs -- distracting -- but understand that's part of OC's vibe.

The food was amazing. Service was a little on the slow side for it not being busy but the server was sweet and staff great.

Our server Paityn did a great job of taking care of my mom and I. The food was great, everything was hot, tasty and out quickly.

I’m not the type of person to go to a pizza place and order something other than pizza so I ordered the classic pizza and it was pretty good. The service was good no complaints here.